Police brutality or slip & fall?

February 18th, 2008

Click Here to view the story and video on KTBS.com 

A Shreveport police officer has been fired after an incident in which a female prisoner taken into custody on suspicion of DWI wound up lying on a floor at the police station in a pool of blood.

Much of what happened was recorded on a videotape – but there is a gap of undetermined length. During that time, the woman wound up injured. She said she was beaten up; the officer said she fell.

The woman, Angie Garbarino of Shreveport, was argumentative when she was brought to the DWI unit’s office last November. The videotape shows she did not want to listen to Officer Wiley Willis as he read her rights. She was insistent on making a phone call and said so repeatedly.

At one point, Garbarino – who during the episode mentioned the names of attorneys and a police officer she wanted to contact — tried to leave the room but was stopped by the officer and then handcuffed, the videotape shows.

The situation escalated and the videotape shows the officer push the woman against the wall; she fell to the floor crying and telling him not to touch her.

She later tried to leave again. What happened next was outside the view of the camera but the woman can be heard screaming before she is placed back in a chair.

Seconds later, the tape is turned off. It is not known what happened while the tape was off, but when it was turned back on Garbarino was lying on the floor on her side in a pool of blood.

Willis turns her on her back and tells her, “Lay down; don’t move, ”the videotape shows.

“I can’t believe you just did what you just did. I really can’t,” she said.

The officer left the room. Another officer came in shortly after that to look at Garbarino and then left. At some point, a Fire Department ambulance crew was called. They took her to the hospital.

Garbarino’s lawyer, Ron Miciotto, said she suffered a broken nose, a severe cut on her forehead, two broken teeth and bruises on her arms and shoulder. Pictures taken of her later show two severely bruised eyes, as well as other bruises.

Willis was fired earlier this month for what officials said was his handling of the incident. No criminal charges were filed accusing him of injuring the woman.

Willis said she slipped and fell and hit her head. Individuals familiar with the case said Garbarino does not remember what happened, although she can be heard on the videotape saying she was beaten. The videotape is off at the time in question.

“The whole situation could have been avoided if the officer had followed procedure,” Miciotto said, referring to when an uncooperative person should be taken to jail.

“It was something that needed to be handled internally,” Police Chief Henry Whitehorn said of the decision not to file charges against the officer. “There was not enough (evidence) to pursue criminal charges.”

Willis’ attorney, Eron Brainard, said Willis did not beat the woman. Her injuries, he said, happened when she fell while trying to leave the room again.

“Although very unfortunate, her injuries were caused by her own erratic behavior – her failure to comply with lawful, reasonable and standard instruction for arrested persons,” Brainard said.

Garbarino faces trial on charges of DWI and hit and run driving. She will fight them in court, Miciotto said.

My favorite place in the ArkLaTex is…

November 19th, 2007

How would you finish that sentence? Monday through Thursday, November 19-23, 2007, the KTBS 3 First News team is taking you to their favorite places. Ed Walsh started us off Monday morning in Natchitoches, Louisiana. Sonja Bailes took us through her old stomping grounds, Lincoln Parish. Keep watching to see where Mark Rowlett takes us on Wednesday, and Rick Rowe on Thursday. We also want to know what feels like home to you. Leave a comment about your favorite place in the ArkLaTex, and tell us what makes it so special to you.

Hannah Montana Craze

November 15th, 2007

It was one of the most anticipated concerts of the year. Hannah Montana, aka Miley Cyrus, took center stage at the CenturyTel Thursday night in Bossier City in the “Best of Both Worlds” tour. The tour has made national headlines after frustrated parents and fan club members complained about ticket availability. Mona Vienne has been trying for months to get her daughter, Makensie, tickets, but refused to pay the outrageous prices online. But in the end, she hit the jackpot. “Finally I went in and said best seats available and lucked up and got on the 8th row, on the floor.” The best part is Mona paid regular price for the tickets. So what are your thoughts on the Hannah Montana craze and ticket fiasco? Share your thoughts here on the Grapevine.

Young and old march in Jena

September 20th, 2007

Thousands came to Jena, Louisiana, Thursday to march and rally in support of the six teenagers who’ve come to be known as “The Jena 6.”Louisiana State Police estimate the crowd at 12,000, but others say there were many more in attendance.

It was the first civil rights march for younger generations from the ArkLaTex.

Civil rights activist Rev. Al Sharpton said a new generation had stepped forward.

Students from north Louisiana made the trip to Jena for this historic event.

Many young people we spoke with heard stories from the parents and grandparents about the civil rights movement in the 1960’s.

 

Thursday’s gave them a chance to voice their opinions and create memories of their own.

Rev. Harry Blake, a veteran of the civil rights movement, said the challenge now is to see where we go from here.

School scores show need for more change

September 6th, 2007

 Statewide school performance scores in Louisiana showed little or no improvement in academic performance scores or did worse than last year, the state education superintendent said today.

Twelve schools in Caddo Parish are on the lists of academically unacceptable, including Bethune Middle School for a fifth consecutive year. There was one each in DeSoto and Natchitoches parishes.

Caddo schools listed as academically unacceptable for a third year are Barret Elementary, Caddo Heights Elementary, J.S. Clark Middle, Fair Park High, Green Oaks High, Linear Middle, Linwood Middle, Oak Park Elementary, Booker T. Washington High and Woodlawn High.

Those on the list for the first year were Ingersoll Elementary in Shreveport, Mansfield Elementary in DeSoto Parish and George L. Parks Elementary in Natchitoches.

Fewer schools in Louisiana met their improvement targets than in the previous eight years of the accountability program, and state schools Superintendent Paul Pastorek said this points to a need for greater reforms and help at the state level.

Deputy Superintendent of Education Ollie Tyler, the former schools superintendent in Caddo Parish, called for the acceleration of efforts to remake public high schools.

Under the accountability system, which calls for ongoing improvement in student achievement, schools are given performance scores based on a scale of 0-180. Of the nearly 1,120 schools, 70 were deemed academically unacceptable, meaning they scored below 60 on the scale. That’s down from last year, but the number is expected to rise when schools affected by the 2005 hurricanes fall under the accountability system again.

In all, 288 schools showed minimal growth, 184 showed no growth and 290 were labeled as schools in decline. By contrast, 104 showed “recognized growth” and 163, exemplary growth. 

Sagging Saga

August 29th, 2007

We may never know for sure why people decided to start wearing their pants lower and lower, eventually exposing their underwear and more. Some sources say it started as a trend from prison culture. Inmates aren’t allowed to have belts, and if their uniforms are too big, there’s nowhere for pants to go but down.

However it happened, the trend is now mainstream. Cities in Louisiana, and around the country, are trying to bring waistlines back up. It started when the small town of Delcambre in south Louisiana passed a city ordinance creating penalties for wearing pants that turn underwear into outerwear. Mansfield passed its own ban earlier this month. People cited for sagging starting on September 15 will have to pay a $150 fine and court costs, or spend up to 15 days in jail. Now Shreveport and Alexandria have also passed ordinances banning the big britches.

Atlanta, Georgia, has also passed an ordinance to outlaw the sagging pants, but legal experts there have said the rules would not hold up in court because telling someone how to dress violates the constitutional right to freedom of expression.

What do you think about the bans? What do you think about sagging pants?

What’s in a day?

May 28th, 2007

  

            Today is a simple day off work for some.  With all holidays it is easy to forget why you head to the lake to celebrate or what we are commemorating at all.     

            On the last Monday of May we honor those who have died while serving our country.  Today a single flag will be placed on each grave at Arlington National Cemetery. Will anyone in this area visit a grave today? Does anyone have a special tradition to honor fallen soldiers? It is easy to forget this day is not just any day away from our intense schedules.  It’s a day to stop and recognize the men and women who have died fighting for our country.  Not to be confused with Veterans Day that honors EVERYONE that has served in the military.   

So, while you chomp down on that perfectly scorched hotdog or feel the wind blow in your hair as you cruise down the Red River … make sure, if only for one second, you think about the young men and women that lost their lives fighting for you, to be here, in the United States of America.

33 dead after shootings at Virginia Tech

April 17th, 2007

Professors: Cho was very troubled BLACKSBURG, Va. (AP) — A very troubling picture is emerging of the man responsible for the deadliest shooting rampage in U.S. history.Virginia Tech creative writing professor Lucinda Roy told NBC’s “Today” show that Cho Heung-Sui was one of the most disturbed students she had ever seen. Roy says she tried to get help for Cho and wishes more could have been done.

Professors and classmates were alarmed by the violence and perversion in his class writings. One former classmate says he and others were seriously worried that Cho could be a school shooter.

Acclaimed poet Nikki Giovanni, who was one of Cho’s professors, told CNN that her students were so unnerved by Cho’s behavior that she had security check on her room and eventually had him taken out of her class.

One of Cho’s suitemates told ABC’s “Good Morning America” that he wasn’t friendly and would just give one-word answers.

Virginia Tech student relates dramatic escape from gunman

BLACKSBURG, Va. (AP) — A student described what it was like at Virginia Tech’s Norris Hall when the gunman burst into his classroom. Twenty-year-old Alec Calhoun says he was in a mechanics class on the second floor when he and his classmates heard a thunderous sound in the room next door. When they heard screams, Calhoun says they realized it was gunfire. He says he began flipping desks to use as hiding places while others dashed to the windows and began jumping. Calhoun says he also ran to the window, and was about the eighth or ninth person to jump. He also thinks he was the last. Calhoun says two students behind him were shot.Calhoun says just before jumping, he glanced back at his professor, who stayed behind — perhaps to block the door. The professor was killed. 

A look at some of the students and faculty killed in the Virginia Tech shootings (Source: AP)ROSS ABDALLAH ALAMEDDINE - a 20-year-old sophomore from Saugus, Massachusetts, who had just declared English as his major. On Facebook-dot-com, friends have created a memorial page that describes him as “an intelligent, funny, easygoing guy.” Zach Allen, who attended Austin Preparatory School in Massachusetts with Alameddine, remembers him as an “amazing kid,” who always made him smile. A family friend says Alameddine was killed in the classroom building. Alameddine’s mother says she is angered by how victims’ relatives were notified of the shooting. She says it was “outrageous” that she didn’t hear about her son’s death until a quarter to eleven Monday night.

CHRISTOPHER JAMES BISHOP - 35, taught German at Virginia Tech. He also helped oversee an exchange program with a German university. He decided which German-language students at Virginia Tech could attend the German university to improve their language skills. His Web site says he had spent four years living in Germany, learning German, teaching English, drinking wheat beer, and “wooing a certain fraulein.” That’s a reference to his wife, Stephanie, who also teaches in Virginia Tech’s German program.

RYAN CLARK - called “Stack” by his friends, many of whom he met as a resident assistant at Ambler Johnson Hall, where the first shootings took place. The 22-year-old from Martinez, Georgia, was a fifth-year student working toward degrees in biology and English, and a member of the Marching Virginians band. His friend Gregory Walton says Clark was “just one of the greatest people you could possibly know.” Walton learned from an ambulance driver that Clark was among the dead. Walton says he doesn’t think he ever saw Clark mad in the five years he knew him.

JOCELYN COUTURE-NOWAK - a French instructor, is credited with being instrumental in the creation of the first French school in a town in Nova Scotia. She lived there in the 1990s with her husband, Jerzy Nowak, the head of the horticulture department at Virginia Tech. A student who identifies herself as DeAnne Leigh Pelchat describes her gratitude to Couture-Nowak on a Web site. In part she wrote, “You’ll always have a place in my heart.”

DANIEL PEREZ CUEVA - a 21-year-old from Peru, whose mother says he was killed while in a French class. According to the Virginia Tech Web site, Perez Cueva was a student of international relations. On RPP radio in Peru, his father said he was trying to obtain a humanitarian visa from the U.S. consulate here. A spokesman at the U.S. Embassy in Peru says the student’s father “will receive all the attention possible when he applies” for the visa.

KEVIN GRANATA - a professor of engineering science and mechanics, who served in the military and later conducted orthopedic research in hospitals before coming to Virginia Tech. At the school, he and his students researched muscle and reflex response and robotics. The head of the school’s engineering science and mechanics department says Granata was one of the top five biomechanics researchers in the country working on movement dynamics in cerebral palsy. One engineering professor says Granata was successful and kind, someone who “still found time to spend with his family” coaching his children in many sports and extracurricular activities.

CAITLIN HAMMAREN - a 19-year-old sophomore from Westtown, New York, who majored in international studies and French. The principal at Hammaren’s high school says “Caitlin was a leader among our students.” The principal says Minisink Valley High School students and teachers shared their grief at a counseling center set up in the school.

EMILY JANE HILSCHER - a 19-year-old freshman majoring in animal and poultry sciences, who was known around her hometown as an animal lover. A family friend says Hilscher worked at a veterinarian’s office and cared about animals “her whole life.” The family friend says Hilscher lived on the same dorm floor as victim Ryan Clark. Fellow 19-year-old Will Nachless says Hilscher “was always very friendly,” “very outgoing,” “and she was great in chemistry.”

JARRETT LEE LANE - a 22-year-old senior civil engineering student who was valedictorian of his high school class in tiny Narrows, Virginia. It’s just 30 miles from Virginia Tech. Lane’s high school has put up a memorial to him that includes pictures, musical instruments and his athletic jerseys. Lane played the trombone, ran track, and played football and basketball at Narrows High School. His brother-in-law Daniel Farrell calls Lane fun-loving and “full of spirit.”

MATTHEW J. LA PORT - a 20-year-old freshman from Dumont, New Jersey, who was attending Virginia Tech on an Air Force ROTC scholarship and belonged to the school’s Corps of Cadets. La Porte was a graduate of the Carson Long Military Institute in New Bloomfield, Pennsylvania. He credited the academy with turning his life around. Tuesday, the school posted a memorial photograph of La Porte in his school uniform on its Web site. According to his profile on a music Web site, La Porte’s favorite artists were Meshuggah, Metallica, Soundgarden, Creed and Live.

LIVIU LIBRESCU - an Israeli engineering and math lecturer, was known for his research. But his son says his father will be remembered as a hero for protecting students as the gunman tried to enter his classroom. Librescu taught at Virginia Tech for 20 years and had an international reputation for his work in aeronautical engineering. Librescu’s son says his father’s students sent e-mails detailing how the professor saved their lives by blocking the doorway of his classroom from the approaching gunman before he was fatally shot. His son says students started opening windows and jumping out.

G.V. LOGANATHAN - born in southern India and had been a civil and environmental engineering professor at Virginia Tech since 1982. The 51-year-old won several awards for excellence in teaching, had served on the faculty senate and was an adviser to about 75 undergraduate students. His brother tells a news channel in southern India that Loganathan had been “a driving force for all of us.” He says, “We all feel like we have had an electric shock. We do not know what to do.”

DANIEL O’NEIL - a graduate student in engineering and played guitar and wrote his own songs. He posted them on a Web site, resident-hippy-dot-com. A friend, Steve Craveiro, describes him as smart, responsible and a hard worker, someone who never got into trouble. O’Neil graduated in 2002 from Lincoln High School in Rhode Island and graduated from Lafayette College in Easton, Pennsylvania, before heading to Virginia Tech, where he was also a teaching assistant.

JUAN RAMON ORTIZ - A native of Puerto Rico, Juan Ramon Ortiz, was teaching a class as part of his graduate program in civil engineering at Virginia Tech. The family’s neighbors in the San Juan suburb of Bayamon remember Ortiz as a quiet, dedicated son who decorated his parents’ one-story concrete house each Christmas and played in a salsa band with his father on weekends. Marilys Alvarez says she heard Ortiz’s mother scream from the house next door when she learned of her son’s death. Alvarez says she’s wanted to study in the United States, but is now reconsidering.

MARY KAREN READ - born in South Korea into an Air Force family and lived in Texas and California before finally settling in the northern Virginia suburb of Annandale. The 19-year-old considered a handful of colleges, including nearby George Mason University, before choosing Virginia Tech because it was a popular destination among her Annandale High School classmates. Her aunt says she thinks Read had struggled adjusting to Tech’s sprawling 26-hundred-acre campus. But she had recently started making friends and looking into a sorority. Karen Kuppinger says they became concerned after three or four hours passed and she hadn’t picked up her cell phone or answered her e-mail. The aunt says the family thought “she would pop up.”

JEREMY HERBSTRITT - loved to chat, so much so that high school classmates voted him “Most Talkative.” He was 27, with two undergraduate degrees from Penn State, one in biochemistry and molecular biology from 2003, and another in civil engineering from 2006. He grew up on a small farm just outside the central Pennsylvania borough of Bellefonte, where his father, Michael, raised steer and sheep. His career goal was to be a civil engineer, and he talked of getting into environmental work after school.

RACHAEL HILL - a freshman studying biology at Virginia Tech after graduating from Grove Avenue Christian School in Henrico County. Hill, an only child, was popular and funny, had a penchant for shoes and was competitive on the volleyball court. A Grove Avenue school administrator says, “Rachael was a very bright, articulate, intelligent, beautiful, confident, poised young woman. She had a tremendous future in front of her.” He says “Obviously, the Lord had other plans for her.” Her father, Guy Hill, said the family was too distraught to talk about Hill on Tuesday, but relatives were planning to have memorial events later in the week.

LAUREN MCCAIN - On her MySpace page, Lauren McCain listed “the love of my life” as Jesus Christ. Her family said the 20-year-old international studies major became a Christian some time ago. Her uncle, Jeff Elliott, told The Oklahoman newspaper that she was an avid reader, was learning German and had almost mastered Latin. She was home-schooled and had worked at a department store for about a year to save money for college.

MICHAEL POHLE - of Flemington, New Jersey, was 23. He was to graduate in a few weeks with a degree in biological sciences. In high school, Pohle played on the football and lacrosse teams. One of his old lacrosse coaches, Bob Shroeder, describes him as “a good kid who did everything that good kids do.”

JULIA PRYDE - a graduate student from Middletown, New Jersey. She was an “exceptional student academically and personally,” according to the chairman of the biological systems and engineering department where Pryde was seeking her master’s degree. Her hometown has been touched by tragedy before. It lost 37 residents or past residents in the Nine-Eleven terrorist attacks.

Read what Virginia Tech students are saying about the massacre at these blog sites:

Blacksburg Beacon

Bryce’s Journal

College football legend Eddie Robinson dies

April 4th, 2007

robinson.bmp

 

Legendary former Grambling State University football coach Eddie Robinson died overnight. He was 88.

Robinson died at Lincoln General Hospital in Ruston, where he had been taken Monday afternoon after having trouble breathing. He had suffered for years from Alzheimer’s disease.

Robinson was Grambling’s head football coach from 1942-97. He won more than 400 games and at one point was the winningest coach in college football history. He was the first college coach to rack up 400 wins, completing his career with 408 wins, 165 losses, and 15 ties. Robinson’s teams had just eight losing seasons and won 17 Southwestern Athletic Conference titles and nine national black college championships. Robinson sent more than 200 players to the NFL.

“Today we mourn the loss of a great Louisianan and a true American hero,” Louisiana Governor Kathleen Blanco reacted to the news Wednesday, April 4, 2007. “Generations of Louisianans will forever benefit from Coach Robinson’s fight or equality. He worked to create the Bayou Classic football match-up, which will remains one of college football’s greatest events an important part of Louisiana’s culture. During the most recent Classic, I was honored to stand with the Robinson family to launch the Eddie G. Robinson Museum, which will stand as a meaningful tribute to this great Louisiana legend. My heart and prayers go out to Doris and the Robinson family and the entire Grambling State community.”

The times are set for us to say our final goodbyes to Eddie Robinson. A public viewing will be held in the Rotunda of the State Capitol in Baton Rouge on Monday. Public viewing begins at 10:00 a.m. Coach Rob’s funeral will be at 11:00 a.m. Wednesday at Grambling’s new assembly center behind the stadium that bears Robinson’s name.

Underage Drinking Crisis

March 26th, 2007

last-dance-rectangle.jpg

The U.S. Surgeon General’s Office estimates 11 million teens and young adults are drinking before their 21st birthdays this year. The Surgeon General’s research shows teenagers who start drinking before the age of 15 are five times more likely to have problems with alcohol later in life. New evidence also suggests alcohol is more damaging to developing adolescent brains than previously thought. Did you wait until your 21st birthday to down an alcoholic drink? If you’re not 21 yet, are you waiting? What were your experiences with underage drinking? And if you’re a parent now, how do you approach the subject of alcohol with your children?

Online Resources:

One Great River

Alcoholics Anonymous

Al-Anon/Alateen

MADD

Substance Abuse